Comment On The Tale of a Spam

As hard as it may be to believe, there are actually quite a few people out there who like spam. There's the Lonely Type, sitting at home on a dateless Saturday night just waiting to hear "You've Got Mail!" Then there's the type who just feel good inside knowing that someone hooked them up with an awesome deal on \/1@Gr@ and a H0/\/\3 M0rTgaG3. And then there's the Hormel folks, whose 2006 Annual Report stated that 33% of SPAM purchases were for "gag and joke purposes specifically related to unsolicited email." But Adam Golebiowski isn't in this crowd; like most of us, he doesn't like spam at all. [expand full text]
« PrevPage 1 | Page 2 | Page 3Next »

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 10:46 • by MET
Nice :)  And I had been meaning to ask when the beginning of the day for this site was.  It must be midnight somewhere on the planet round about now.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 10:51 • by AC
I LOVE YOU ADAM GOLEBIOWSKI

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 10:51 • by Volmarias
109678 in reply to 109673
Ah, those charming fellows from Nigeria and Russia. Who wouldn't want their webs? 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 10:54 • by hk0
Ha ha ha ha. He said "telnet".

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 10:58 • by Coditor

OMG!! Finally being able to get the spammer where it hurts :) That must have been a glorious feeling to be able to remove all his files :)

Personally I would have posted the FTP account details to as many websites and forums as I could in the hope that it would be picked up by those that search the internet for open servers to store their movies on :P

Brilliant but I have to say that the biggest WTF is that Adam actually visited the link in that obvious spam email.

Coditor

Hrm

2007-01-04 11:05 • by Baggy McBagster

 

That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

 

 

 

 

 

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:10 • by SM
109689 in reply to 109686
Anonymous:

 

That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

 



I probably would have done the same thing.  And I wouldn't have had any trouble sleeping at night afterwards either, if you get my drift.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:12 • by Anonymous
109690 in reply to 109686

One might point out that in the US, an unsolicited email pretending to be from an 'old highschool friend' is also illegal...

But yeah. Internet vigilantism is a dangerous occupation these days.

 

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:21 • by <slight hand gesture />You don't need to know my name
109693 in reply to 109689
Anonymous:
Anonymous:

That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

 

I probably would have done the same thing.  And I wouldn't have had any trouble sleeping at night afterwards either, if you get my drift.

Wait a minute... No one ever said that Adam was responsible for anything more than snooping...

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:24 • by Anonymous
109695 in reply to 109686
In a few small number of countries, unsolicited bulk emailing is illegal. In those countries, some have the doctrine of "unclean hands" which means that the individual who instigates an act which breaks the law is fully responsible for all the consequences, including personal losses - that individual is unable to sue/prosecute anyone who thwarts or even takes advantage of the instigator.

A simple example - some 419 spammer wants to scam you for £80,000 in order to release a $20,000,000 windfall... you claim that you cannot get the bank to release those funds immediately because you are £200 short of paying the £800 release fee. Spammer sends you the £200. You can now legally pocket that money and walk away.

Of course this is not true in all countries - check your local laws ...

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:26 • by Tony
109696 in reply to 109693

Wouldn't it have been a lot more fun to discover the spammer's personal email address(es) and change every field in his database of email addresses to his own?  You know, so that next time he sends out a mass email, he gets 150,000 copies of the spam, gets pissed off cause his inbox won't load, so he calls his ISP, who then discover that they've got a spammer on their hands, and they drop him like a hot rock, and then post a story here about how some idiot inadvertantly turned himself in for spamming.

That, and the "post the link everywhere so that people can use the open server to store movies" thing... LOL.
 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:29 • by Trinian

God bless us every one.

What a beautiful story. :`)

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:29 • by Ciaran

From a bit of Googling around, I'm guessing the page in question was probably an older or newer version of http://web.archive.org/web/20060423052254/www.emoneyworks.com/lender/climate_city.asp
 . It's not *that* version because it doesn't have a username/password combo. (the actual page is down now)

 It would make sense though. That page is about 2.3MB.
 

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:31 • by Ed
109700 in reply to 109690

But where is the line between internet vigilantism and electronic self defense?  You are, in a sense, disarming your attacker.  The downside is, of course, that the spammer was merely interrupted, and not prosecuted.

I say pass the info on to the folks at one of the big-name ISPs who are losing half their bandwidth to these pirates... They will happily have their investigators and lawyers stomp on any spammers they can.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:31 • by Maurits
Bonus points if he replaced the list of emails with uce@ftc.gov and spamtraps.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:32 • by Slepnir

Just deleting it won't do any good.  The spammer probably has a backup.  If the bulk mailing program was some kind of script, I would have sprinkled it with "sleep(50)" and leave the spammer to wonder why it suddenly takes 100x as long to send out his mailings...

 

If you have the time, you can write a script to poison the list of names (insert random letters / numbers into the username of the address, etc.)

 

Catchpa "paste".  It's not just for snacktime anymore.
 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:33 • by sir_flexalot
I have found massive spam email lists on google before, it is a scary thing to see a directory of tens of text files, each megs in size, that are just lists of email addresses in alphabetical order.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:34 • by peterg22

> then there's the Hormel folks.. 33% of SPAM purchases were for "gag and joke purposes specifically related to unsolicited email

Yep, have to admit that I was one of them. Actually my tin of Spam reached it's "consume by" date 3 years ago and I'm just trying to find the courage to open it up and have a look inside. IMHO it'll be as rotten as the ****** that keep sending me unsolicited mail.
 

 

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:35 • by Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? Over.
109705 in reply to 109686

Anonymous:
That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

I seem to remember reading somewhere that it wasn't illegal to walk through an open door......

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:36 • by G Money
109707 in reply to 109695

I believe that it's still illegal for you to pocket the money, but the good part is that the spammer can't win a lawsuit against you.

 Oh, what you can learn by watching the People's Court.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:37 • by Patrick
Sadly that was probably not the spammer's box, but one he had hijacked for the purposes of spamming :(

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:48 • by Dave
109712 in reply to 109708

I run a car enthusiast's forum which was spammed by someone advertising his website to claim money back from UK banks. Nice helpful guy.

Quick whois on the domain gets his name and address, bit of google work gets his home phone number and cell, few gory details on his personal life and company he works for.

Didn't appreciate me spamming his forum with his personal info, but I think he got the hint.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:52 • by Vlad Patryshev
109714 in reply to 109678
Russia? I bet you never met a charming fellow from Russia. Should I remind you of Sergey Brin, or Sergey Dmitriev would be enough?

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 11:53 • by rgz
109715 in reply to 109686

 That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he
didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing
strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few
American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.



Bullshit! In a world where the law is sold to the highest bidder, vigilantism is the only moral left. I hate that "the law is the law" attitude, is common sense dead in America?

Edit: Now that I think about it, most people here agree with Adam's actions, so common sense is not dead, only ilegal. 


Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:55 • by Dale Williams
109716 in reply to 109704
Anonymous:

> then there's the Hormel folks.. 33% of
SPAM purchases were for "gag and joke purposes specifically related to
unsolicited email

Yep, have to admit that I was one of them.
Actually my tin of Spam reached it's "consume by" date 3 years ago and
I'm just trying to find the courage to open it up and have a look
inside. IMHO it'll be as rotten as the ****** that keep sending me
unsolicited mail.
 

 

 

If
you think that the Spam in the can is rotten after only 3 years,
obviously you never saw the old spam-cam from the early days of the
Internet.<G>

I also worked with an metalurist from Iowa
many years ago.  As a teenager he did summer work for
Hormel.  He would say, "Pigs go in, Spam comes out, no
remainder."  Just couldn't bring myself to eat anymore Spam after
that.

 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 11:55 • by John Cowan
From what I understand, a typical spammer's account is used once and then abandoned.  It's easy enough to get new ones, and the ISP will catch on fast, though (alas) usually not fast enough.  So while what Adam did was very soul-satisfying, it almost certainly had zero impact on the ability of that spammer to stay in business.  Ditto all the other suggestions for what to do with the list or the account.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:05 • by noehch
109719 in reply to 109702
Anonymous:
Just deleting it won't do any good.  The spammer probably has a backup.  If the bulk mailing program was some kind of script, I would have sprinkled it with "sleep(50)" and leave the spammer to wonder why it suddenly takes 100x as long to send out his mailings...

If you have the time, you can write a script to poison the list of names (insert random letters / numbers into the username of the address, etc.)

You might be right about the backup.
But, seriously...if the author of the page is dumb enough to place user/pass in the readily-available source code of his page...what makes you, honestly, think he was smart enough to back up anything?
Cause, I'm not giving him the benefit of the doubt.

Yeah, he's probably not expecting anyone tech-savvy--meaning anyone who knows what "View -- Source" is and what NotePad (or other) then displays--to actually stop by his site.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 12:12 • by l1fel1ne
109721 in reply to 109693

Well here in Canuckland, section 342.1 might be worth a quick read:

http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/c-46/280843.html

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:20 • by nickfitz
109725 in reply to 109716
Anonymous:

I also worked with an metalurist from Iowa
many years ago.  As a teenager he did summer work for
Hormel.  He would say, "Pigs go in, Spam comes out, no
remainder."  Just couldn't bring myself to eat anymore Spam after
that.

 


People who work in these places always have such horror stories. Some years ago I was a barman (bartender in American, I think) in a pub around the corner from a sausage factory, and there was never any shortage of workers on their way home telling me horror stories about how sausages are made. Come payday, virtually all of them were carrying big freezer packs of sausages (major discount at the factory shop) to take home to their families. If the stories were true, they wouldn't have been eating anything from that place, never mind feeding it to their kids.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 12:23 • by noehch
109726 in reply to 109705
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? Over.:

Anonymous:
That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

I seem to remember reading somewhere that it wasn't illegal to walk through an open door......

Another way to look at it:
A hostage shoots you, while you're robbing a bank, with a concealed gun.
Do you sue him/her for "assault with a deadly weapon" and for damages considering all the money you otherwise would've had?

Edit: yeah...the extremities are obviously different...

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:38 • by noehch
109732 in reply to 109725
nickfitz:
Anonymous:

I also worked with an metalurist from Iowa many years ago.  As a teenager he did summer work for Hormel.  He would say, "Pigs go in, Spam comes out, no remainder."  Just couldn't bring myself to eat anymore Spam after that.

People who work in these places always have such horror stories. Some years ago I was a barman (bartender in American, I think) in a pub around the corner from a sausage factory, and there was never any shortage of workers on their way home telling me horror stories about how sausages are made. Come payday, virtually all of them were carrying big freezer packs of sausages (major discount at the factory shop) to take home to their families. If the stories were true, they wouldn't have been eating anything from that place, never mind feeding it to their kids.

While I have no way of knowing what horror stories you were told...

Based on those I've heard--including gutting, factory sanitation, etc.--I'd say it's more so being able to stomach the facts.

The idea that people will stop eating the food, once they know what's in it, is one of the ideas behind Fast Foot Nation.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:48 • by ptomblin

I've only engaged in "internet vigilantism" twice, both times when I was younger and more foolish.

 The first time was the first time I saw somebody probing my web server for those "_vti" vulnerabilities.  I fed the same URL back to the site sending me the probe, and got a director listing of their computer and realized they were infested, but probably didn't know it.  I wanted to shut down their computer, but couldn't figure out how to do it, so I sent a "deltree" command to delete one of the guy's games so he'd realize that he was infested.

The second time was when I discovered that ftp.frys.com was an open ftp server, and people were using it as a porn and warez repository.  After I copied some of the porn for *ahem*study*ahem*, I deleted the whole porn and warez repository.  No, it wasn't nice, and it wasn't helpful, but I figured it would only be a slight slowdown for the porn and warez kiddies.



 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:49 • by Guy
109738 in reply to 109732
noehch:
nickfitz:
Anonymous:

I also worked with an metalurist from Iowa many years ago.  As a teenager he did summer work for Hormel.  He would say, "Pigs go in, Spam comes out, no remainder."  Just couldn't bring myself to eat anymore Spam after that.

People who work in these places always have such horror stories. Some years ago I was a barman (bartender in American, I think) in a pub around the corner from a sausage factory, and there was never any shortage of workers on their way home telling me horror stories about how sausages are made. Come payday, virtually all of them were carrying big freezer packs of sausages (major discount at the factory shop) to take home to their families. If the stories were true, they wouldn't have been eating anything from that place, never mind feeding it to their kids.

While I have no way of knowing what horror stories you were told...

Based on those I've heard--including gutting, factory sanitation, etc.--I'd say it's more so being able to stomach the facts.

The idea that people will stop eating the food, once they know what's in it, is one of the ideas behind Fast Foot Nation.

 "Fast Foot Nation," would that be Kenya?

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 12:49 • by pauluskc
109739 in reply to 109719

Hello....  remember for the file to get to the web server, 98.6% of the time it is FTP uploaded.  Every FTP programs I've ever used doesn't delete the source file when the upload is complete.  So he/she (can't leave those evil vindictive vixens out of this) probably has the list on his/her hard drive and perhaps already uploaded it to those other dozens of accounts.

Haven't any of you ever used the web before????

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 12:55 • by simcop2387
109741 in reply to 109726
Absolutely!

http://www.overlawyered.com/archives/01/mar3.html#0321a

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 13:03 • by noehch
109743 in reply to 109741

Anonymous:

I thought I had heard of something like that happening...

but, I was thinking it was an off-duty cop...sadly, I'm sure it's happened more then once, though...

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 13:10 • by Lady Nocturne

I'm truly surprised no one has posted the link to the P-p-p-powerbook yet...

 http://www.zug.com/pranks/powerbook/

 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 13:29 • by Hypersapien

I recall a website where the navigation links didn't work at all (at
least in Firefox, they worked in IE). When I looked at the source code,
the buttons were set up like this

 <tr>
<a href="..."><td><img ...></td></a>
 </tr>

It
kind of makes sense that this was the web site for one one the most
badly written computer games ever. It was a trucking game where there
was no collision detection (not even with bridges that went over deep
chasms, you fell right through them) and when you raced against the
computer, the opponent  truck matched your speed exactly the whole way.

To this day, I'm pretty sure the whole thing was someone's tax dodge.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 13:30 • by jtwine
109755 in reply to 109700

Anonymous:
But where is the line between internet vigilantism and electronic self defense?  You are, in a sense, disarming your attacker.  The downside is, of course, that the spammer was merely interrupted, and not prosecuted.

Disarming an attacker is knocking the weapon from his/her hand and reach or otherwise rendering the attacker unable to use the weapon (shot in the shoulder, knocked out, etc.).  Destroying the property of another can surely get you in trouble, even if you do it to the lowest of the low.

Not that I do not agree with the actions taken, mind you...  I do!

 -=- James.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 13:30 • by merreborn
109756 in reply to 109704
Anonymous:

> then there's the Hormel folks.. 33% of SPAM purchases were for "gag and joke purposes specifically related to unsolicited email

Yep, have to admit that I was one of them. Actually my tin of Spam reached it's "consume by" date 3 years ago and I'm just trying to find the courage to open it up and have a look inside. IMHO it'll be as rotten as the ****** that keep sending me unsolicited mail. 

 
I purchased a can of spam as a pet back in highschool, and named him eric.  He's still sitting in a box somewhere, better part of a decade later.

Should have seen the looks on their faces at city hall when I went to get him licensed.  I had a license for my pet dog, eric, and my cat, also called eric.
 

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 13:32 • by jtwine
109759 in reply to 109705

Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? Over.:
Anonymous:
That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.
I seem to remember reading somewhere that it wasn't illegal to walk through an open door......

Perhaps.  But what you do while in there may be...

Peace!

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 13:47 • by obediah
109764 in reply to 109693
Anonymous:
Anonymous:
Anonymous:

That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

 

I probably would have done the same thing.  And I wouldn't have had any trouble sleeping at night afterwards either, if you get my drift.

Wait a minute... No one ever said that Adam was responsible for anything more than snooping...


I'm sure the agents from Homeland Security appreciate the *wink* *nudge* cleverness about as much as they appreciate humour. And yeah, thanks to the overlapping knee-jerk insane computer laws and knee-jerk insane terrorism laws, they could be the guys to show up at your house.

When you combine the Patriot Act and the DMCA, filling in a web form with a made up name can get you put on a plane to gitmo.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 14:02 • by steamer25
That's HIGH-larious tiny-E.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 14:14 • by steamer25
109771 in reply to 109741
What kind of idiot tries to take hostages at the gun club?

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 14:18 • by Mr Ascii
109774 in reply to 109736
ptomblin:

The second time was when I discovered that ftp.frys.com was an open ftp server, and people were using it as a porn and warez repository.  After I copied some of the porn for *ahem*study*ahem*, I deleted the whole porn and warez repository.  No, it wasn't nice, and it wasn't helpful, but I figured it would only be a slight slowdown for the porn and warez kiddies.

 While downloading network drivers one weekend a bunch of years ago, I chanced on an open FTP site with quite a collection of warez. I emailed the admin to let him know what was going on and got a reply that basically said I was full of sh!t and they didn't have a problem. Apparently the people taking advantage of the server would clean up their trading area on Sunday night so that it wouldn't be detected. I replied back to his email suggesting he check his logs and left it at that, I never heard back from him.
 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 14:41 • by merreborn
109780 in reply to 109774
Mr Ascii:

 While downloading network drivers one weekend a bunch of years ago, I chanced on an open FTP site with quite a collection of warez. I emailed the admin to let him know what was going on and got a reply that basically said I was full of sh!t and they didn't have a problem. Apparently the people taking advantage of the server would clean up their trading area on Sunday night so that it wouldn't be detected. I replied back to his email suggesting he check his logs and left it at that, I never heard back from him.
 

Ah, the old "If I bitch out the reporter, maybe the problem will go away" approach to system administration.
 

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 14:43 • by Uhoh
If you delete it, they'll immediately know that something was wrong and that their list was bad. Instead, I recommend using Perl to do something like tr/trnslaeiouy/mmbbvvxxcttee/ (swap a bunch of letters around in a non-reversible way), that way they won't know that their list has been trashed unless they inspect it.

Re: The Tale of a Spam

2007-01-04 14:51 • by Alexandre

That was probably the best WTF I've seen so far.

It's wrong is so many ways that makes it a classic.

Hilarious xD

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 14:52 • by FrostCat
109784 in reply to 109726
noehch:
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? Over.:

Anonymous:
That's a heck of a lot of laws the guy violated there, just because he didn't like that company's (annoying but legal) marketing strategy.  I'm going to assume the spammer probably has few American legal resources but I reckon I'd have left the place alone.

I seem to remember reading somewhere that it wasn't illegal to walk through an open door......

Another way to look at it:
A hostage shoots you, while you're robbing a bank, with a concealed gun.
Do you sue him/her for "assault with a deadly weapon" and for damages considering all the money you otherwise would've had?

Edit: yeah...the extremities are obviously different...

 

Regardless of the fact that your example is different, it happens.  Google Tony Martin, who shot intruders, after being robbed repeatedly and the cops basically told him there was nothing they could do.  He spent more time in jail than the thug who broke into his house--and the government initially gave the guy money to sue Martin for loss of wages and injuries.

Re: Hrm

2007-01-04 14:58 • by Franz Kafka
109786 in reply to 109771

steamer25:
What kind of idiot tries to take hostages at the gun club?

 

The same kind that sues the victims afterwards. 

« PrevPage 1 | Page 2 | Page 3Next »

Add Comment