Comment On When it's Done

Dan F.'s copy of Half-Life 2 will be done uninstalling in 16 days. Valve had originally planned for the uninstaller to work in 10 minutes, but they hit some snags and were forced to delay. By contrast, Duke Nukem Forever will take just over a year to uninstall. [expand full text]
« PrevPage 1 | Page 2Next »

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:04 • by Orson (unregistered)
hmm thats an odd one, what was being used in the background? Norton?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:08 • by rewind
Looks like he is using the ClearType applet too...text looks nice and crisp.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:09 • by pnieuwkamp
Hurray for the ten thousand very small files Steam(TM) comes with...

Addendum (2007-02-16 12:15):
Make that 8834 files in 528 folders.

10gb for 33 files, 3gb for the remaining 8301... Which includes, I must say, almost everything from the Silver package, so it is not _all_ HL2, but still..

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:15 • by Saladin
I applaud any jab at DNF's currently ten-year production timeline.

Even Prey was eventually released, though, so there's hope.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:30 • by Asd (unregistered)
Why would you want to uninstall half life 2!!!!

Seriously though, steam/source engine supports archive files, so why do the feel they have to extract every fecking thing?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:30 • by JF (unregistered)
Glenn Lasher:
First?


Lame?


Yes!

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:33 • by jeb (unregistered)
Meta-WTF: What is with the (R) in Half-life(R)? Do they want a registered trademark symbol? That's an ANSI character you know. Good old Alt-(0174). Of course if you got all Unicode you could use 00AE in hexadecimal/174 in decimal for ®. Lazy bastards.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:34 • by Orson (unregistered)
121040 in reply to 121038
JF:
Glenn Lasher:
First?


Lame?


Yes!

No Quack?

captcha: waffles, what I just got done emptying from my bowels

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:37 • by Mikademus
Those 16 days are included in "expecting playing/completion time" in the ads...

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:40 • by Wizou (unregistered)
Use Alt-PrintScreen to capture the dialog box only..
so you don't have to crop the window manually out of the full screen picture

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:43 • by cassis (unregistered)
I like those famous "Windows minuts" or "Windows seconds"... You know, the kind of measure that has a random value as unit !

captcha: tesla, this one isn't a random value unit :)

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:47 • by strictnein
Ahh... what would you want to uninstall Half Life 2? One of the better single player FPS experiences of the last couple of years. And HL2: Episode 2 looks to be amazing.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:49 • by AndrewB (unregistered)
Wow, incredibly lame WTF.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:51 • by nobody (unregistered)
This reminds me of the time I realized I needed a new computer.
I was installing Visual Studio .NET (please don't say that is the WTF) and the estimated time to completion was increasing, not decreasing.
Eventually, the time did decrease and it installed, but it took a couple of hours.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:52 • by anonymous (unregistered)
I have worked on the Quake codebase, and I admire the Valve guys. I am a opensource guy, and hate DRM with my brain and guts, but Steam is something gamming need to exit a hit driven economy. Games only live a few days on the shops, so this force a "create a huge game, and create ads like crazy" that is bad for gamming, is hurting, and kill whole game companys.

The tecnical solution to make Steam posible whas some layer of indirection to the fisical filesystem. That layers add whatever you need to create DRM, but also the very complex needs to make posible some games reuse resources from other games (Garris Mod with Counter Strike models, etc).

The original Quake game also whas with a very god layer, that layer whas soo good that able modding (simply adding a progs.dat file on a folder, make then load instead files inside pak files).

Half-Life2 whas distributed with DVD and CD files, but once you installed it, whas needed to uncypher stuff, and update with patchs. So installing HL2 whas 3 hours manpower, or something alike (maybe 4 hours).

I have no idea why the uninstaller is braindead on this system, but is a small bug on a amazing complex system that Steam is.



---Tei

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:57 • by matt (unregistered)
121054 in reply to 121053
anonymous:
I have worked on the Quake codebase, and I admire the Valve guys. I am a opensource guy, and hate DRM with my brain and guts, but Steam is something gamming need to exit a hit driven economy. Games only live a few days on the shops, so this force a "create a huge game, and create ads like crazy" that is bad for gamming, is hurting, and kill whole game companys.

The tecnical solution to make Steam posible whas some layer of indirection to the fisical filesystem. That layers add whatever you need to create DRM, but also the very complex needs to make posible some games reuse resources from other games (Garris Mod with Counter Strike models, etc).

The original Quake game also whas with a very god layer, that layer whas soo good that able modding (simply adding a progs.dat file on a folder, make then load instead files inside pak files).

Half-Life2 whas distributed with DVD and CD files, but once you installed it, whas needed to uncypher stuff, and update with patchs. So installing HL2 whas 3 hours manpower, or something alike (maybe 4 hours).

I have no idea why the uninstaller is braindead on this system, but is a small bug on a amazing complex system that Steam is.



---Tei


i used to have dreams about quake. i wish i had never played it so i could play it again for the first time...

captcha: howdy ... sup dog?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 12:58 • by CorporateFelon (unregistered)
121055 in reply to 121051
nobody:
This reminds me of the time I realized I needed a new computer.
I was installing Visual Studio .NET (please don't say that is the WTF) and the estimated time to completion was increasing, not decreasing.
Eventually, the time did decrease and it installed, but it took a couple of hours.


That also always happened to me with Visual Studio.

Microsoft really needs to fix the algorithm for all those time estimations.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:00 • by Anonymousalicious (unregistered)
You claim to have worked on the Quake engine, yet use words like "patchs", "gamming" and "companys"?

Good thing C++ isn't spelling-sensitive. Oh wait...

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:06 • by Mr Firsty (unregistered)
Last Post

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:18 • by coredump (unregistered)
121059 in reply to 121057
Are you sure?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:18 • by noone (unregistered)
very last post

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:21 • by Sebastián
121061 in reply to 121060
last one, ad infinitum

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:23 • by rbowes
121062 in reply to 121031
Orson:
hmm thats an odd one, what was being used in the background? Norton?


As a loyal employee of Symantec, I find that.... hilarious :)

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:24 • by BillyG the Magician (unregistered)
121064 in reply to 121055
CorporateFelon:
Microsoft really needs to fix the algorithm for all those time estimations.


Dude, Microsoft DID "Fix" the algorithm for all those time estimations. It starts out giving you a reasonable time for install and ticks away giving the illusion that it's proceeding according to schedule. It's only when you check the clock at start and finish that you realize they're consistently gaming you with underestimates.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:25 • by Sebastián
All those algorithms to calculate remaining time are useless. There's a lot of things that can happen while installing or uninstalling that make those messages really incoherent. They should just stick to the progress bar and perhaps a "remaining tasks to complete".

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:27 • by After the Last Post (unregistered)
FIRST!!!

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:29 • by After the Last Post (unregistered)
121067 in reply to 121062
rbowes:
Orson:
hmm thats an odd one, what was being used in the background? Norton?


As a loyal employee of Symantec, I find that.... hilarious :)

No, it's gotta be McAfee.
McAfee == No CPU Cycles left to do anything

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:29 • by gl (unregistered)
121068 in reply to 121062
rbowes:
Orson:
hmm thats an odd one, what was being used in the background? Norton?


As a loyal employee of Symantec, I find that.... hilarious :)


That brings to mind the old joke... "Why is Peter Norton always standing there with his arms folded?"

"He's waiting for Norton Desktop to load."

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:32 • by MedO (unregistered)
Oh my, this DOES remind me of a thread titled "The last one to post here wins", over at h2g2. It started September 2003. At first most posts just consisted of "I win", then followed discussions about WHY the poster would ultimately win etc, and more... bizarre posts. The thread was finally closed in June 2006, and the moderator left the following final message:

I did warn you guys about being abusive...

I think 37,000 posts of this stuff is probably enough.

I win.


Captcha: smile :-)

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:39 • by malfist
121070 in reply to 121069
MedO:
Oh my, this DOES remind me of a thread titled "The last one to post here wins", over at h2g2. It started September 2003. At first most posts just consisted of "I win", then followed discussions about WHY the poster would ultimately win etc, and more... bizarre posts. The thread was finally closed in June 2006, and the moderator left the following final message:

I did warn you guys about being abusive...

I think 37,000 posts of this stuff is probably enough.

I win.


Captcha: smile :-)


37,000!!!!
*boggled*
One thing I can say, humans are competative

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:39 • by H3SO5
121071 in reply to 121065
Sebastián:
All those algorithms to calculate remaining time are useless. There's a lot of things that can happen while installing or uninstalling that make those messages really incoherent. They should just stick to the progress bar and perhaps a "remaining tasks to complete".


Agreed.

The worst "remaining time" algorithm that I've found is on the SuSE Linux installet. It gives extremely inaccurate readings (such as, 3 hours for a basic Linux install).

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:48 • by stevekj
121073 in reply to 121056
Anonymousalicious:
You claim to have worked on the Quake engine, yet use words like "patchs", "gamming" and "companys"?

Good thing C++ isn't spelling-sensitive. Oh wait...


I liked "fisical" myself.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:49 • by malfist
121074 in reply to 121071
H3SO5:

The worst "remaining time" algorithm that I've found is on the SuSE Linux installet. It gives extremely inaccurate readings (such as, 3 hours for a basic Linux install).


I noticed that to, it gave me <2:00 untill installation but it was finished in about a hour and a half. The most accurate one's I've seen is with Ubuntu, it's Update Manager is almost always dead on.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:58 • by 1337 h4x0r (unregistered)
121076 in reply to 121056
Anonymousalicious:
You claim to have worked on the Quake engine, yet use words like "patchs", "gamming" and "companys"?

Good thing C++ isn't spelling-sensitive. Oh wait...


Maybe english isn't his first language... you know, there are people living outside Anglophonia *gasp*

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 13:59 • by Builder (unregistered)
During any uninstall, if a dialog ever pops up and asks you something like: Are you sure you want to remove these shared libraries? Well, the estimated time left factors in how long it takes you to hit ok and continue with the uninstall.

What if you started the uninstall before you went to bed and woke up the next morning and hit ok? Well, that's easy... you get that huge number of minutes left to uninstall.

It's not really a wtf.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:00 • by Sebastián
121078 in reply to 121074
An hour and a half? That's pretty much a lot for a Linux install. I've completed a Debian install from the net in about that time. But installs from CD/DVD only take 30-45 mins as much. Do SuSE install the whole media?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:01 • by Sebastián
121080 in reply to 121076
laik mi and a lot of oder pipol.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:06 • by DF5 (unregistered)
121081 in reply to 121054
matt:


i used to have dreams about quake. i wish i had never played it so i could play it again for the first time...

captcha: howdy ... sup dog?


That is the most romantic thing I have ever heard.

So great in the idea, but saddly impossible in real life.
-DF5

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:12 • by Welbog
I get it. The Real WTF (tm) is that someone is trying to uninstall Half-Life 2.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:33 • by Nick (unregistered)
I haven't installed HL2 since I finished it years ago, but I recall it taking a LONG time to install, what with the decrypting and all. I'd start it back up, were it not for steam...

How ironic, my captcha was QUAKE.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:47 • by Romeo (unregistered)
121086 in reply to 121068
gl:
rbowes:
Orson:
hmm thats an odd one, what was being used in the background? Norton?


As a loyal employee of Symantec, I find that.... hilarious :)


That brings to mind the old joke... "Why is Peter Norton always standing there with his arms folded?"

"He's waiting for Norton Desktop to load."


Best IT joke of the year (since now)

CAPTCHA: Doom - a good game also

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 14:50 • by Dan F. (unregistered)
yay, my WTF got submitted. to answer questions:
- no, there is no norton or mcafee installed (EVER.)
- yes, cleartype is installed on my beautiful 24" widescreen LCD.
- it actually took like 4 minutes to uninstall
- i was uninstalling because i wanted to move it off to another harddrive and windows doesnt support symbolic linking

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 15:02 • by Rick (unregistered)
121091 in reply to 121087
Dan F.:

- i was uninstalling because i wanted to move it off to another harddrive and windows doesnt support symbolic linking


Actually, yes it does.

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/205524

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 15:05 • by TankerJoe
121092 in reply to 121087
Dan F.:
yay, my WTF got submitted. to answer questions:
- no, there is no norton or mcafee installed (EVER.)
- yes, cleartype is installed on my beautiful 24" widescreen LCD.
- it actually took like 4 minutes to uninstall
- i was uninstalling because i wanted to move it off to another harddrive and windows doesnt support symbolic linking


You win... oh, wait...

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 15:16 • by kilroy (unregistered)
LAST!!

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 15:55 • by pnieuwkamp
121098 in reply to 121087
Dan F.:
- i was uninstalling because i wanted to move it off to another harddrive and windows doesnt support symbolic linking

Move the directory, remove ClientRegistry.blob and restart Steam ;)

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 16:29 • by Duston (unregistered)
121106 in reply to 121044
Is that like "Football seconds" or "Basketball seconds?"

I'd say the captcha, but it's way too much like a President I strongly dislike.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 16:40 • by Hanneth
I was copying a large amount of data in Windows Vista about a week back and it showed 1d 6h to transfer. I took the amount of data, I divided it by the transfer rate after watching to make sure the transfer rate didn't change to much. I came up with about 11m. It took about 11m.

Yes, time estimation code isn't all that precise, but it's not hard to write one that's in the ballpark.

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 16:54 • by Anonymous (unregistered)
So what isotope did you use to get this kind of half-life?

Re: When it's Done

2007-02-16 17:08 • by Zylon
121111 in reply to 121032
rewind:
Looks like he is using the ClearType applet too...text looks nice and crisp.

"Applet"? It's just a checkbox setting under Display Properties.
« PrevPage 1 | Page 2Next »

Add Comment