- Feature Articles
- CodeSOD
- Error'd
-
Forums
-
Other Articles
- Random Article
- Other Series
- Alex's Soapbox
- Announcements
- Best of…
- Best of Email
- Best of the Sidebar
- Bring Your Own Code
- Coded Smorgasbord
- Mandatory Fun Day
- Off Topic
- Representative Line
- News Roundup
- Editor's Soapbox
- Software on the Rocks
- Souvenir Potpourri
- Sponsor Post
- Tales from the Interview
- The Daily WTF: Live
- Virtudyne
Admin
And this is why you should keep business accounts separate from private ones on all services. Same for phone numbers, emails and literally everything else.
Admin
GDPR ( (EU) 2016/679 ) gives you the right to request that a controller (e.g., a company, a government agency, or an association) promptly rectify any inaccurate personal data concerning you.
Admin
After multiple instances of less-than-helpful customer support, I've started emailing the address listed in their imprint directly. So far, these representatives have been a lot more helpful.
I can also second European's suggestion of throwing the GDPR at them. Preferably directly to their data protection officer. Helped a friend of mine with a different company.
Admin
I'm not sure if the GDPR is applicable in this case. It only applies to natural persons. But having (had) a VAT number implies a company (i.e. a non-natural person).
Admin
Time to close or abandon both those accounts, and open a third fresh one with no old addresses or old VAT numbers.
Admin
Oh yes, this is horrible. There is, however, a way to manage those VAT settings, with a link buried deep in their documentation. I just google it each time: https://www.amazon.pl/VAT_registration
Of course, this doesn't solve the problem entirely, because Amazon will now issue an invoice for each purchase, but at least there's an "Edit" button there. I still recommend a separate account, though.
Admin
What the VAT number is might be a company thing - yourself being associated with that business should be a personal thing, so I'd hope it's still applicable.
Admin
I know it's not quite the same thing but every time I try to log in to the UK tax office website, they offer me a choice of sending an SMS to my mobile or a voice-call to my long-defunct landline. Unfortunately it's not possible to remove the landline from my account because it is not recorded against the account.
Admin
Or stop after abandoning both accounts ;)
Admin
Amazon does not have "customer support." Kafka would nod in recognition.
Admin
Honest question: Why is VAT still a thing?
Admin
Customer support chatbots are TRWTF.
Admin
Amazon has surpassed Bank of America and Capital One for distinction in customer disservice.
Admin
I would give up after the first failed attempt and then buy everything tax free. If the tax police try to get me I can say I made an effort to fix it and the rest is on Amazon.
Admin
I had an issue with a return recently and attempted to use their AI chatbot to guide me through my options. It was full of odd-ball assumptions and misinformation to a shocking degree. It was as if they had intentionally insulated it from being able to see my actual account details, but in addition to that it also didn't have accurate information about the amazon website itself...
Admin
Yes, but were you able to cancel your cable TV?
Admin
As opposed to what? No tax on things being purchased? Or American-style sales tax that is paid at every step rather than only by the end user?
Admin
Perhaps you typoed, or perhaps I misunderstoo.
But American style sales tax is only paid at the end-consumer level. Business-to-business transactions involving ingredients or components of the next-level product are not taxed. So the opposite of VAT which is taxed at every production level.
Things a US business buys that they don't sell on in any form, such as admin supplies or fuel are sales-taxed. Because the business is the ultimate consumer of that item. And as a general matter services aren't taxed at all.
From my POV as an American with some, but not a lot, of experience with VAT regimes, it seems to me VAT would be a huge improvement over our income tax and sales tax system. Largely because it is so good at being self-enforcing. ANd has some hope of staying progressive if designed that way.
Admin
Can you delete your Amazon account? Starting a new one is optional. If they really don't want your business...
Addendum 2026-10-19 17:38: Although, if you try to start a new account using the same email address, it's possible they won't let you because you already deleted your old one and deletion is permanent. In that case, that proves they don't want your business!
Admin
Send them an invoice for wasting your time.
Admin
Neither: I misremembered.
VAT is also only paid by the final consumer, but also at every step in between manufacturer and consumer. However, everyone who sells the thing on (commercially) rather than using it can reclaim the VAT they paid. This has always seemed a needless bureaucratic hassle to me, but I guess it benefits the government as long as that makes more in interest on the tax it has in its accounts than the cost of the bureaucracy to pay it back.
Admin
The actual benefit to the government is that it's much harder to evade VAT with fake bookkeeping because each link in the chain of tax paying and goods custody in effect rats on the outfits on both sides of them. Their own desire to keep their taxes as low as possible low ensures the other guy can't underreport.
Admin
Even if taxes are a pain in the **** they do pay for roads, healthcare, and other social security. Maybe not in the US, but mostly in the rest of the world they do. Some countries even have free healthcare.
Admin
It works exactly the same in the US. Repaving and repair work happens all the time and it comes from taxes. As someone who travels fairly often, I have long witnessed such work going on in various places myself. Are there places with bad roads that don't get attention? Sure. That's a local government issue (county or city/town.) I can also say I have seen bad roads in Europe during travels there as well.
As for "free healthcare", there is no such thing. You just pay much more in taxes to cover it instead of paying directly to an insurance plan.
Admin
Here in Australia they pay for healthcare, but I don't think you could say they pay for roads. Unless you classify putting a temporary patch onto another temporary patch onto another patch on a road that has long since fallen apart because water has gotten under it as maintaining the roads. A mate of mine almost got killed by a pothole while on the way to a protest about the road conditions. It gets extra fun at the intersection of a road maintained by the state government and a road maintained by local government. Both will claim that the intersection is eachother's responsibility and do nothing and in the end the residents have to patch the road and clean the drains.
Admin
Yes and no. There are two chief differences. The first is that the costs of any given thing are less than in america on an equivalent plan because the government healthcare system is not out to price gauge the people. So paying the equivalent gets you much further. And the second is that everyone, rich or poor, is on the same insurance plan. So even though the software engineer pays more into the system than the garbage collector they both get the healthcare they need and not the healthcare they can afford. Which is frankly superior because I don't want my garbage collectors getting sick and making my city look like Paris.
Admin
Here in Australia, with GST, as a business, when you submit your quarterly BAS (Business Activity Statement), you enter how much GST you paid on your purchases and how much GST you collected from your sales.
If the GST you paid on purchases exceeds the GST you claimed on sales, the ATO will issue a GST refund.
Means that realistically, for most businesses, they should never end up paying GST at all, so a lot of B2B is done at Nett excluding GST when quoting figures, and B2C is Nett including GST.
Thankfully GST has remained at 10% since 2000 when it was introduced, unlike NZ where I believe they started at 10% and then moved up to 12% and then finally to 15%.
Addendum 2026-10-22 18:01: GST refund of the difference.
Admin
In Germany, healthcare is also not tax funded. The rule is simple: Everyone has to be health insured. There are two ways to do that: public and private insurance.
Public insurance (there are different providers. It's not just one.) is available to everybody. The public ones must not reject you for your health record. You pay a certain amount, which is split between you and your employer[1]. That amount is payed immediately by your employer to the insurance provider, so the money never hits your account. The amount you pay depends on your wage, not your health.
Private insurance is only open to people earning above a certain amount per year. It should be a well thought through decision to take private insurance, because you cannot go back. And here your rate works differently. For young people the rate is usually cheaper because they need the doctor less. However, with age this turns around and private insurance becomes rather expensive. So you better save money for your retirement. As I said: you can't go back[2].
I think the key points are a) Everybody must be insured, b) Public providers must not send you away and may not throw you out, and c) the rate depends only on the means you have. It's not cheap let alone free, but it gives you a peace of mind, that a small accident won't send you down the debt spiral.
Notes: This is for employees. For the self-employed things work differently, but I'm not familiar with that.
[1]: I think the "employer" part does not count towards your income tax. [2]: There are certain exceptions to this rule. "Expensive rates" is not one of them.
Admin
Thanks for that explanation. I find it genuinely interesting. If a bit more complicated than what I am used to.
It works something similar over where I am at. The fundamental basic premises is always the same. Everyone pays into the compulsory fund and than everyone can also use the common good when required. And nobody in the system is actively working to price gauge you because the objective is public health and its long term benefits to society and not immediate profit to the healthcare provider.