• (cs) in reply to TInkerghost
    TInkerghost:
    Harry:
    The real WTF is that the union didn't file a grievance.
    I had a union file a grievance against me because I picked up a board with nails in it (warehouse floor) & threw it in the garbage (3 feet away). Evidently the proper protocol is to kick it to the side & then advise the janitorial staff that it is there - so they can take care of it when they get around to it.

    And now you've learned from this story that the proper reaction is to start leaving your fast food trash on the floor for them.

  • PG (unregistered) in reply to KenW
    KenW:
    Matts:
    I worked in a union plant, a GM factory, 20+ years ago. We had no problem at all with the union regarding the computers. This story is not only false, it is old and false.

    Your logic is faulty. Because your experience 20+ years ago with one particular facility and one particular union (UAW) doesn't match the described scenario, you're assuming that all unions and all facilities don't match either.

    I've worked in a GM UAW plant for close to 20 years. They were/are nasty when it comes to computers. They insisted that they should be doing things like fixing large UNIX servers. We got around that one (it's under a service contract, you can't get the spares, and don't have the training), but a UAW guy had to stand next to the guy that came in to fix them. You could not pick up a PC and move it from one desk to another if your office moved.

    A GM IUE or IBEW plant was much better to work.

    I've also worked at power plant with IBEW. No problem working with them.

  • ClaudeSuck.de (unregistered) in reply to Bob N Freely
    Bob N Freely:
    Philipp:
    I think the real WTF here is that second-grade farting thing. How can something like this be on a permanent record when already working? Please tell me that this was a joke! Poor Americans (I guess Jake is american, right?)

    Don't underestimate the Permanent Record. Somewhere, in a dark government records vault is a folder with my name on it. In it, there is surely a report concerning the incident in which I received a sticker for a perfect score on a spelling test in third grade, which read "Have a ducky day!" I proceeded to scratch out the d in "ducky" and replace it with an f, and some nameless classmate ratted me out. The fallout from this act has overshadowed my life for decades. I'm certain that's why the FBI never called me for an interview when I sent them my application.

    I would expect such rubbish in countries like Russia or China. I mean, keeping a note about someone making fart noises or writing a nasty word is ridicoulous. This is something like everyday practice at school. When I think how often I said "Scheisse" at school, I would have been shot by the age of 15.

    And if the FBI is reading this post: Scheiiiissseeee, Scheisse, Scheisse, fart, fart fart, fuck, fuck, fuck. Now, I deserve being thrown in prison?

  • (cs) in reply to Matts
    Matts:
    I worked in a union plant, a GM factory, 20+ years ago. We had no problem at all with the union regarding the computers. This story is not only false, it is old and false.

    You didn't have management that wanted to get out of paying workmans compensation for an incident that happened while you were turning on the computer.

  • ClaudeSuck.de (unregistered) in reply to Andrew
    Andrew:
    spacix:
    It takes less than 25mA arm to arm to kill you. Human skin requires >7 Vrms to break the skin...

    All joking in line and up front, I suggest you go grab a 50Vac with 1A current hand to hand and test this theory :D

    The real wtf could have been him sticking his hand into a live enclosure without shutting it's power off and adding a tag to cord ;)

    That "its the amps that kill" thing is so misleading. Voltage provides the force that makes current fatal.

    To use the analogy of a gun. Voltage = the gases expanding and pushing the slug. Current = the momentum of the slug. Unless there is a great voltage, the current will not exist. I cannot throw a .222 slug hard enough to hurt someone seriously. I fire that same slug out of a gun and I can tear off limbs.

    So yes, the current does do the killing, just like the momentum of the slug, but you have to have the force(voltage) present first.

    You have probably never touched the spark plug on a running engine. That's some 5000 V with some µA and doesn't kill you at all. Whereas I wouldn't like to be in the starter circuit when you start the same engine and that's a mere 12 V current but some 100 A and that could be dangerous.

  • ClaudeSuck.de (unregistered) in reply to EE Wannabe
    EE Wannabe:
    spacix:
    It takes less than 25mA arm to arm to kill you. Human skin requires >7 Vrms to break the skin...

    All joking in line and up front, I suggest you go grab a 50Vac with 1A current hand to hand and test this theory :D

    The real wtf could have been him sticking his hand into a live enclosure without shutting it's power off and adding a tag to cord ;)

    Yes but...

    I'm not aware of exact numbers relating to the human body, but low voltage does not have the potential difference necessary to induce a large current "arm-to-arm". 50VAC may indeed be (relatively) safe, even if the circuit is capable of 10A or more as long as the resistance "arm-to-arm" is greater than 2Kohm. I = V/R

    Don't apply Ω's (please don't capitalise) law to AC

  • ClaudeSuck.de (unregistered) in reply to Max
    Max:
    Thumbs up for the persistent employee.

    Actually it was resistance, not persistence.

  • (cs) in reply to Aen
    Paul Johnson:
    Then Mrs Thatcher got elected and globalisation started to roll.
    Next comment:
    Aen:
    Only in America...

    Ohhhh, the irony!

  • (cs)

    Electricity newbie here. It seems like there are several experts leaving comments here, so here goes...

    I was recently changing a light switch in my home. I touched a live wire after disconnecting it from the switch to unbend it; the old switch had a screw that the wire wrapped around, and the new switch had a hole that the wire got inserted into on the back, and a screw clamped down onto it from the side. So, I first tried to unbend the wire with my hands, and I was fine (no shock), but the wire wouldn't bend. So, I got my Leatherman pocket tool--which has a metal handle--and grabbed (more like clamped down on) the wire with the built-in pliers. I got a really nasty shock from that, which I could feel inside my head. I was tingling for a little while afterward and I had a headache for the rest of the day. I eventually found a pair of needle-nose pliers--with a rubber handle--and finished the job with those. You can bet I touched the wire with the tip of the needle nose pliers lightly at first. I think it took like four or five pokes and prods before I felt comfortable enough to grab onto it.

    A couple of questions to those more knowledgeable here about electricity: Why didn't I get shocked from touching the wire bare-handed, but I did get shocked when an extra piece of metal was placed between my hand and the wire? Was I in any sort of danger while doing this, or was the shock basically harmless? What are some good resources to learn more about electricity so I could accurately predict and prevent something like this from happening again? I've had a few different people try to explain to me the differences between amps, volts, hertz, watts, ohms, AC, DC, etc., and how they all relate to each other, but it just hasn't sunken in yet.

  • Shawn G. (unregistered) in reply to Matts

    Just because it didn't happen to you doesn't mean it didn't happen to me. This story is most patently true. I can provide names, dates and location, as well as witnesses to back me up. Just because GM's union works correctly doesn't mean other locations don't. We're talking TVA here, in 1990.

    The reason this occurred is that the person who left the relay cover off was buddies with the safety officer and they loved to find loopholes to their advantage. If you don't think things like that happen, then I don't know what to tell you.

  • Ed (unregistered)

    Back when I used to be an inspector in steel plants I was one of the only non-union employees there. I got dinged for unauthorized use of welding equipment. How did I use it? The welder left cables laying on a catwalk, with a welding rod still attached and the welder turned on. Since there was no one from the electrical union around, I was not permitted to turn on the lights. This resulted in me tripping over the live welding lead and causing the welding rod to weld itself to the catwalk.

    Needless to say I in in a new line of work now.

  • iusto (unregistered) in reply to cparker
    cparker:
    Electricity newbie here. It seems like there are several experts leaving comments here, so here goes...

    I was recently changing a light switch in my home. I touched a live wire after disconnecting it from the switch to unbend it; the old switch had a screw that the wire wrapped around, and the new switch had a hole that the wire got inserted into on the back, and a screw clamped down onto it from the side. So, I first tried to unbend the wire with my hands, and I was fine (no shock), but the wire wouldn't bend. So, I got my Leatherman pocket tool--which has a metal handle--and grabbed (more like clamped down on) the wire with the built-in pliers. I got a really nasty shock from that, which I could feel inside my head. I was tingling for a little while afterward and I had a headache for the rest of the day. I eventually found a pair of needle-nose pliers--with a rubber handle--and finished the job with those. You can bet I touched the wire with the tip of the needle nose pliers lightly at first. I think it took like four or five pokes and prods before I felt comfortable enough to grab onto it.

    A couple of questions to those more knowledgeable here about electricity: Why didn't I get shocked from touching the wire bare-handed, but I did get shocked when an extra piece of metal was placed between my hand and the wire? Was I in any sort of danger while doing this, or was the shock basically harmless? What are some good resources to learn more about electricity so I could accurately predict and prevent something like this from happening again? I've had a few different people try to explain to me the differences between amps, volts, hertz, watts, ohms, AC, DC, etc., and how they all relate to each other, but it just hasn't sunken in yet.

    The resistance between the metal and your skin is inversely proportional to the contact area. That's maybe half a cm^2 when you grabbed the wire and tens of cm^2 with the metal pocket tool, so many tens of times less resistance using the tool. It probably was somewhat dangerous if it did funny things inside your head like that.

  • Bob N Freely (unregistered) in reply to iusto
    iusto:
    cparker:
    Electricity newbie here. It seems like there are several experts leaving comments here, so here goes...
    The resistance between the metal and your skin is inversely proportional to the contact area. That's maybe half a cm^2 when you grabbed the wire and tens of cm^2 with the metal pocket tool, so many tens of times less resistance using the tool. It probably was somewhat dangerous if it did funny things inside your head like that.

    As a side note, in the future, if you're going to be working on electrical stuff in your home, find and open the breaker switch that controls that circuit first. Then you won't have to worry about getting electrocuted. I'm kind of surprised you didn't do that after getting shocked the first time.

  • Alan (unregistered) in reply to ClaudeSuck.de
    ClaudeSuck.de:
    You have probably never touched the spark plug on a running engine. That's some 5000 V with some µA and doesn't kill you at all. Whereas I wouldn't like to be in the starter circuit when you start the same engine and that's a mere 12 V current but some 100 A and that could be dangerous.

    10 points to the person who guesses what the resistance of the circuit is so that 12V produces 100A. A bonus 10 points if you can figure out the reason why you could safely grab that circuit, or even insert yourself into the circuit (in series) without suffering more than a case of the tinglies.

  • PG (unregistered) in reply to ClaudeSuck.de
    ClaudeSuck.de:
    Don't apply Ω's (please don't capitalise) law to AC

    Why not? V, R and I are now complex numbers when dealing with AC.

  • (cs) in reply to Bob N Freely
    Bob N Freely:
    As a side note, in the future, if you're going to be working on electrical stuff in your home, find and open the breaker switch that controls that circuit first. Then you won't have to worry about getting electrocuted. I'm kind of surprised you didn't do that after getting shocked the first time.

    Make sure to put a sign "DON'T TURN ON! PEOPLE WORKING!" on the switch. There are too many idiots around.

  • Jean Naimard (unregistered)

    Long ago, between two jobs, I was giving a hand to a friend who operated a small retail store in the basement of a house (this was one of those neat “jobs” where you paid yourself straight out of the till every day before leaving — yeah, I’m that trustworthy).

    One day, when I was keeping the fort, the landlord shows up with a plumber. “The tenant upstairs has no hot water”. So I go with them in the furnace room where the water heater is located.

    The plumber opens the fuse box, and puts two fingers straight accross the two 220 volt phases.

    I know that when you work on high-voltage circuits, you should use only one hand, but this was pretty extreme…

    (No, there wasn’t any juice)

    (CAPTCHA: “persto” — Why not “pesto”? It tastes much better)

  • (cs) in reply to SimonTeW
    SimonTeW:
    One wire won't kill you if you can't complete the circuit (via another wire or via a path to ground). Birds on a wire prove this every day.

    This is wrong. Very wrong. A small amount of current flows through the birds. It isn't much, because the voltage difference between their feet is small, and dry skin is relatively high resistance. But current flows up one bird's leg and down the other.

    A small amount of current flowed through your dad. If the voltages involved had been extreme (though not unheard of in industrial settings), he would have fried. Without touching the ground or "completing a circuit".

    Think of it this way: if you build a small canal parallel to the Mississippi, will water magically stay in the river? Or will water flow through both?

  • Yeah, that probably qualifies (unregistered) in reply to EE time

    "Mad current-regulated power supply" indeed... Most lab power supplies can be operated as either (current-limited) voltage or (voltage-limited) current sources.

    And what equipment, outside of a lab, is powered off such a device? Current regulation is, I imagine, useful in some lab experiments, but not so much in the real world. Imagine trying to power logic off of it: if the PSU determines you're not doing enough thinking, it starts upping your '1' voltage.

  • (cs) in reply to Poirot
    Poirot:
    Ah, you're all a bunch of pussies. The real WTF is that Shawn jumped around screaming "safety officer" like a little girl.
    Lacking in the reading comprehension department, aren't we?
  • Anon (unregistered)

    TRWTF is union labor. Nice.

  • (cs) in reply to Yeah, that probably qualifies
    Yeah:
    >"Mad current-regulated power supply" indeed... Most lab power supplies can be operated as either (current-limited) voltage or (voltage-limited) current sources.

    And what equipment, outside of a lab, is powered off such a device? Current regulation is, I imagine, useful in some lab experiments, but not so much in the real world. Imagine trying to power logic off of it: if the PSU determines you're not doing enough thinking, it starts upping your '1' voltage.

    Many rechargeable battery technologies (like the ones in your cellphone, iPod or laptop) require constant current for part or all of the charge cycle. The laser diodes in your DVD player and in the fibre-optic links that carry this message are basically driven by constant current drivers.

    [Note to experts in the above areas: I know these statements are simplifications !]

  • (cs) in reply to Bob N Freely
    Bob N Freely:
    iusto:
    cparker:
    Electricity newbie here. It seems like there are several experts leaving comments here, so here goes...
    The resistance between the metal and your skin is inversely proportional to the contact area. That's maybe half a cm^2 when you grabbed the wire and tens of cm^2 with the metal pocket tool, so many tens of times less resistance using the tool. It probably was somewhat dangerous if it did funny things inside your head like that.

    As a side note, in the future, if you're going to be working on electrical stuff in your home, find and open the breaker switch that controls that circuit first. Then you won't have to worry about getting electrocuted. I'm kind of surprised you didn't do that after getting shocked the first time.

    I'm kind of suprised he didn't do it before getting shocked the first time. If I'm ever doing anything more than changing a light-bulb I'll shut off the power to that circuit first.

  • Poirot (unregistered) in reply to EvanED
    EvanED:
    Poirot:
    Ah, you're all a bunch of pussies. The real WTF is that Shawn jumped around screaming "safety officer" like a little girl.
    Lacking in the reading comprehension department, aren't we?

    Perhaps, but I make up for it with my sparkling wit and personality.

  • TheSkorm (unregistered)

    I emailed several of my work colleges this article and we all had a good old chuckle as we know the same would happen here. The idea of a watch dog timer setup like that seems kinda silly, and the fact that the relay was left open was just stupid. Does this person work in Rio Tinto by anychance?

  • ClaudeSuck.de (unregistered) in reply to GrandmasterB
    GrandmasterB:
    GrandmasterB:
    Gustavo is my hero. Awesome story of giving it to the man.

    Shawn G is my hero, I mean. Got the stories mixed in my RSS reader.

    WTF

  • Loren Pechtel (unregistered) in reply to danixdefcon5
    danixdefcon5:
    I was kind of expecting a Darwin Award nominee by then, but it seems like common sense prevailed after all. The "one wire won't kill you" myth is dangerous indeed...

    So long as it's truly only one you're safe. Observe power line workers working on live wires. They're very careful about touching only one and ensuring there is no ground path.

    I personally have touched 100,000 volts with no effect--I was careful about ground paths. This wasn't actually dangerous as there wasn't the current behind it to do more than hurt if you made a mistake. (And all of us did at times.)

    I've also seen a teacher at 300,000 volts. He did get a bit hurt but only from being careless. It was after the demonstration was over and he forgot to get rid of the charge properly. He was no longer touching anything, the generator was even off. He stepped down from his insulator--and limped around the room for the rest of the class period when his body discharged (simple capacitance can pack a punch at that sort of voltage) through his little toe.

  • Loren Pechtel (unregistered) in reply to alegr
    alegr:
    Body resistance mostly depends on skin. Under that, your blood is just salty liquid with quite good conductance. In very dry conditions (arctic winter indoors), people are known to sample 220VAC with bare fingers.

    Good point. That brings back memories from childhood. I was trying to plug in one of those plugs with a transformer in it in a very awkward position. Somehow I managed to touch both sides of the plug itself while it was far enough in to be hot but not far enough to keep my fingers away. (I have no idea how I managed this--I couldn't see what I was doing at all.) 110VAC, hand to hand. I did feel it but that's all.

  • Neil Ferguson (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    "Human skin requires >7 Vrms to break the skin... Human skin requires >7 Vrms to break the skin..."

    Those comments fall somewhere between wrong and meaningless. Refer to Wikipedia, topic "Electric Shock", paragraph "Lethality of a Shock". Lethality depends on amps (at least 30-100 mA), skin and internal resistance, and perhaps frequency. And of course health, time exposed, and so forth. The power source needs to be strong enough to provide the necessary voltage to drive that current through the body's resistance under existing conditions.

  • kodi (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    What do you mean? 50V or 1A? Human resistance hand to hand is about 200kOhms (hands dry, just checked ;D). So you can have 50V with 0.25mA or 1A with 200kV (situation dramatically changes if ou hve your hands covered with sweat)

  • (cs) in reply to PG
    PG:
    ClaudeSuck.de:
    Don't apply Ω's (please don't capitalise) law to AC

    Why not? V, R and I are now complex numbers when dealing with AC.

    No, you should be using Z for impedance instead of R for resistance if you're treating the terms as complex numbers.

  • Justice (unregistered) in reply to morry
    morry:
    Mmmm. I love the smell of Justice in the morning.

    /mangled cliches ftw

    So you're the monster hiding under my bed!

  • GrigLars (unregistered)

    I used to work for a company that worked with a NOC in a very large telecommunications company in Atlanta. This NOC was a previous AT&T shop many years previously, and the computer nerve center was also a union shop back when it was nothing more than a huge phone switch center.

    Enter "Carl." Carl was in his late 50s, overweight, and barely spoke a word to anyone unless they violated a union rule. Nobody is sure why Carl was on site, but he was the only union guy there. He had in some agreement that only HE was allowed to move equipment in this nerve center. If it was an "electric device," you could not bring it in, move it, or take it out with Carl doing it. This included laptops, cable testers, or anything that used a battery or power cord.

    This was made twice as worse by Carl's attitude. He took forever to fill a work order, couldn't be found half the time, and worked in a closed and locked office where it was assumed he watched porn all day. When he did fill out a work order, he was very abusive to the equipment, often scooting things across the floor with his foot, kicking things out of the way, or using brute force to compensate for his awkward balance.

    It go to the point that people had to sneak in and out of the computer center, and if Carl found out that some new server was move, or put in, or removed, he's either yank things back to where they were, or file a security report of "intruders." Luckily, he wasn't on the floor enough to memorize the location of everything.

    That was over 10 years ago, so I don't know if he's still there.

  • (cs)

    All the union-bashing here is a shame. Unions and their rules do serve an important purpose, but all too often the enforcement of rules is absurdly overdone.

    Its neat how the company tried to use union rules against the employee, and how Shawn was level-headed enough to realize that a head-on assault on bureaucratic lard just doesn't work.

    And give a Twit-Of-The-Week award to the goober who ran around yelling for the Safety Officer.

  • vic (unregistered)

    What country keeps permanent records on workers ? Looks like a life sentence for minor offenses and too much control power over the worker by whoever writes these records.

  • (cs) in reply to snoofle
    snoofle:
    Jake:
    ...yelling a word or two that would make a sailor blush...
    I'm always up for learning new ways to express myself; can you please share those words?

    "Does this look like a Q to you?"

  • Doctor (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    No and no. It normally takes at least 30 mA to kill, and, unless you puncture the skin, you'll need at least 70 volts to push it through.

    Also, you can't "grab 1A of current", the current will depend on your resistance.

  • Richard Neill (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    Something about the way the Union regulations are so pig-headed tells me that this story is set in the USA. That means that the voltage is less likely to be hazardous than it is in Europe. Not that I recommend getting shocked :-)

  • Gust (unregistered)

    Colleague grabbed into a stripped wire some months ago. Shocked him thoroughly, but at the time didn't seem to be a problem. Turns out that it dislocated his shoulder and snapped something inside there. After continuing aches, he is now in physiotherapy. Thing will stay snapped, as an operation probably would break even more there.

    So he got something permanent from this seemingly innocent stint. Please do beware of live current.

  • blog.coldtobi.de (unregistered) in reply to spacix
    spacix:
    It takes less than 25mA arm to arm to kill you. Human skin requires >7 Vrms to break the skin...

    All joking in line and up front, I suggest you go grab a 50Vac with 1A current hand to hand and test this theory :D

    Well, but first you will have to convice Mr. Ohm that his law won't apply here.

    (R_body > 50 Ohm)

  • Anamouse (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    It may not take a lot of current "if properly applied" to be potentially fatal, but it’s also extremely unlikely that the jolt he received traveled up his arm and though his body in that manner. Usually people administer themselves a localized shock that runs from one part of their hand to another part of their hand, and is painful but not life threatening, (unless you are scared to death). That is why we all know lots of people who have been shocked by household current, but it’s very rare to hear about one of them dying. We are usually blessed by the fact that we are not usually well grounded and dry skin has a high resistance, thus we usually just get a good scare and maybe a small burn. All that said, since the potential to do great harm is there, no one should leave powered and exposed connections for any voltage over 50 volts.

  • Peter (unregistered) in reply to GettinSadda
    GettinSadda:
    Did he get his COMPENSATION for a POTENTIALLY fatal electrocution?

    This is very serious and should not be treated simply as a source of humour.

    Compensation for something that has the potential for a serious outcome. As a layman I thought you got compensation for an actual injury. Are you a lawyer?

  • Adam V (unregistered) in reply to Alan
    Alan:
    ClaudeSuck.de:
    You have probably never touched the spark plug on a running engine. That's some 5000 V with some µA and doesn't kill you at all. Whereas I wouldn't like to be in the starter circuit when you start the same engine and that's a mere 12 V current but some 100 A and that could be dangerous.

    10 points to the person who guesses what the resistance of the circuit is so that 12V produces 100A. A bonus 10 points if you can figure out the reason why you could safely grab that circuit, or even insert yourself into the circuit (in series) without suffering more than a case of the tinglies.

    Since no one else did...

    V=IR -> R = V/I = 12V / 100A = 0.12 ohm

    And for the second 10 pts - shouldn't it work in either series or parallel? Adding yourself in series (one site I just found lists the resistance between a person's hands at 1M ohms) raises the resistance high enough that the amperage drops way off. But since your resistance is that high, adding yourself in parallel means more than 99% of the current should flow through the existing circuit anyway.

  • SomeName (unregistered) in reply to spacix

    It depends on wattage. 1 A won't do any harm if it's just 1 V over an hour.

Leave a comment on “Dead Man's Switch”

Log In or post as a guest

Replying to comment #:

« Return to Article