- Feature Articles
- CodeSOD
- Error'd
- Forums
-
Other Articles
- Random Article
- Other Series
- Alex's Soapbox
- Announcements
- Best of…
- Best of Email
- Best of the Sidebar
- Bring Your Own Code
- Coded Smorgasbord
- Mandatory Fun Day
- Off Topic
- Representative Line
- News Roundup
- Editor's Soapbox
- Software on the Rocks
- Souvenir Potpourri
- Sponsor Post
- Tales from the Interview
- The Daily WTF: Live
- Virtudyne
Admin
This is brilliant. It serves two purposes: it keeps out the stupid bots and it keeps out the stupid users.
I propose that all TDWTF comment post CAPTCHAs now feature vector-calculus problems.
Admin
speaking of the captcha test.. the new hotmail one is a pain... took me about 15 attempts.
Admin
(I saw this once or twice on my 2004 trip to the US. Fortunately, I walked back to the machine to take the receipt I had forgotten and noticed the question on the screen. I haven't seen it on the past 2 trips.)
Admin
Actually, I know places where the number for the in-house helpdesk is 911 :)
Admin
Admin
What do people actually think when you photograph young children that are not yours ~.~
Admin
I've seen ATMs that throw the "Multiple of 20" error when they run out of 10 dollar bills; it's just that the GUI is hard coded, so it can't switch to "Press here for $40(or $60) fast cash."
Admin
Admin
Anyone notice that the windows background on the Hong Kong pic looks a lot like the "your copy is pirated" black background?
Admin
Truth be told, I read Code Dependent's comment as stating categorically that all cash machines outside the US accept the card, give out money then return the card. TBH I don't see any other way to read it. I said "Those machines are weird", they said "Well at least you can't walk off and leave your card in one". The obvious implication, and certainly my inference, is that Code Dependent believed that all other ATMs allowed you to take cash out and leave your card behind. That has since been clarified, but I stand by my original inference based on the evidence available at the time.
As to comments being made in a general voicing but seemingly having a specific target, I think Code Dependent's "ATMs here try to anticipate the stupidity of the user" could quite easily be read as a generality aimed at a specific person (i.e. me, the person they were responding to). The simple fact is that if you couch a disparaging remark in a general voicing, you can plausibly deny intending any offense, whether you actually intended any or not. It's a favourite tactic of trolls and flamebaiters, and I can only assume that I've internalised it by spending too much time reading TDWTF ;^)
Oh, and to clarify: I most certainly did not intend any direct offense to any individual with my comments.
Admin
Once upon a time, only rest stop and convenience store ATMs were limited to multiples of $20. I used to work for a company that made ATMs that could handle any amount. They even had a little catch bucket for when it gave change. There was one installed where I worked. I always got $36.41. Just because I could.
Every once in a while, I see one of those machines. They only have $20s and the change bucket sits empty.
Admin
Admin
While every bank sets a default daily maximum, I have yet to do business with a bank that won't change that limit to whatever you want.
Same thing goes for your check-card.
Admin
Awesome! Dance Dance Revolution for MS-DOS! BTW, what level is that? eXPert?
Admin
I wonder what GTK theme Vivek is using.
Admin
TRWTF is hotmail
Admin
I think the people at 911 are starting to get upset with me. Of course, if they had just reset my password like I asked them the first time, I wouldn't have to keep calling them back.
Admin
ATMs must allow the user to enter cents when making a deposit. If they required entry of whole dollars only when making a withdrawal, a user could surely be forgiven for being confused, having to remember to enter cents on deposits but not to enter cents on withdrawals. Also, if a user entered cents when they are not required, a $20 withdrawal becomes $2000. There might be an upper limit, in which case you have to give an error message. If not, a user who wanted twenty bucks finds the machine apitting out a wad of money. The converse error is that the user wants $20 which the machine interprets as 20 cents. At worst it dispenses two dimes, he realizes his error, and asks for another $19.80. As no ATM I've ever used dispenses less than a $10 bill, he probably just gets an error message, realizes his error, and tries again.
Yes, I'm all in favor of making it impossible to enter invalid data, but sometimes that's tricky. You could ask the user to type in the number of each denomination bill he wants, but people don't normally think that way, so that could get confusing too. A user who wants $40 might well type "40" next to the picture of the $20 bill, thinking he's going to get 2 twenties, and then instead he gets $800. Making invalid inputs impossible is a good thing, but not at the price of making inputs non-intuitive or clumsy.
Admin
Admin
That's funny, every ATM I've used in the US only gives out $20 bills. Usually the fast cash option is for $40 and if you manually enter any increment other than $20 you'll get the screen pictured. Sounds like a WTF to me.
Admin
I do AV work (for theatrical productions, not just the standard screen), so I know how to set up a projector properly, and how it will work.
It's shopped. Look at the bottom right corner of the projection. The image leaks over whatever tiles it was originally projected on. This indicated two things:
Also, look at the floor. It's semi-shiny, as you get the glare from whatever windows are in the distance. You would get the same sort of effect with the projector, a big bright spot near the middle of the image.
Shopped.
Admin
Also, if you leave either card or money sticking out of the ATM for long enough (eg if you're dumb enough to walk away leaving the cash!), the machine will pull it back in and reverse the transaction.
Admin
once i couldn't withdraw $50 because, apparently it was not a multiple of $50. too bad i didn't have my camera with me.
Admin
Here (Spain) some Visa cards offers seven Cash Fast options (like 40, 70, 110, 140, 170 and 210... I'll take a photo next time for this WTF-ish quantities). There is another option for other quantities. And, of couse, many many times you have to enter a multiple of 50.
Admin
Also, based on the projector location derived from the keystoning, there should be a portion of the projection visible on the ankle of the woman at the left side of the picture.
Admin
TRWTF is that Alex still thinks the command prompt and DOS are the same thing.
Admin
In my country (Brazil), some ATMs do that, but they are reasonably safe. This prompt disappears quickly (+-5 seconds) and any further transaction would require card insertion before being enacted.
Admin
Just to let all you know, no one of the captcha strings actually worked, so don't bother trying to find out the right one :-)
Admin
I happen to live in Pennsylvania, near Pittsburgh, which I promise is relevant, geez, be patient, this is the first sentance for f's sake, though admittedly, unnecessarily long. The WTF pictures regarding the MAC Machine (or ATM Machine for those with "RAS Syndrome") were immediately obvious to me. I even have the same orange PNC Bank card like the one in the photo and it matches as far as I can see, so I know this is a relatively recent photo, because the orange cards have only been around for a year or so.
PNC Visa Check Card
So here is what happened:
Recently PNC Bank added a new feature to their ATMs that allows you to configure your own custom Fast Cash value. If you configure it, say, on one machine where you normally get $50 (the machine physically at my bank even lets me get down to $5 granularity) and then later hit another machine where it only dispenses $20s, you would get this error.
This is really an end-user WTF instead of a programming WTF, though you could argue a better UI would detect it and round the fast cash value to the nearest dispensable value. The question is, was the end user aware they did it? In fact, they may have even seen the loophole and manufactured a WTF to submit.
Now, regarding the theory put forth as obvious by several posters, that the machine is in fact out of Hamiltons (why not, we have Franklins, I'm just medium pimpin'). A little detective work and you notice the reflection in the screen. It appears to be bottles of possibly Snapple and those iced tea containers with the orange and yellow lids that come in milk containers (especially evident in the 2nd image), I want to say Turner's, but there are several brands around here. It would appear as if the machine is inside a convenience store. I happen to know for a fact that the only stores in this area that have PNC Bank machines are 7-11, which, from my experience only dispense $20s (likely harder to stock when they aren't physically located at a bank).
Anyway, believe me if you want. I've got to get back to debugging this crappy code that someone else wrote. :)
</peace>A common mistake that people make when trying to design something completely foolproof is to underestimate the ingenuity of complete fools. -- Douglas Adams
Admin
This is how the conversation looked to me:
JM: Those ATMs do something funny. CD: Here's a perfectly good reason for doing it that way. JM: You must be implying that ATMs I am familiar with do not deal with that problem. I am insulted. You sound dumb.
So tell me, how was CD supposed to inform about why the ATMs work the way they do without insulting you? He made no comment on other ATMs, he just explained why the ATMs work that way.
Admin
Admin
Error: Amount requested was not a prime number! Error: Amount requested was not a complex power of e!
Admin
The ATM I commonly use has the following issue: It will give any combination of 20s and 50s, which amounts to any multiple of $10 apart from $10 and $30. But if I don't enter .00 at the end of the amount I want to withdraw, it complains that I haven't entered cents. Why does it want me to tell it how many cents I want when it is incapable of dispensing cents? That makes no sense.
I originally read that as 'tentacle fountain'Admin
Sorry, the CAPTCHA was not a multiple of 20. Call 911.
Admin
See the right side of the near corner of the image overlaps the superimposed grid -- so that grid is not the edges of reflective tiles.
The children are also not lit up opposite their shadows.
When faking photos, remember shadows and lighting.
Admin
Or $50 notes. It's been many years since I've seen ATMs that dispense anything other than $20s and $50s. That ATM looks similar to the one I use often, plus I have a Visa Debit card too. :-)
Fastcash $50 makes sense when it spits out a single note.
And on the subject of entering "2000" vs "20" for $20, around here some do it one way and others do it the other. I think the deciding factor would be whether the machine accepts deposits or not.
Admin
Admin
What? Yes it was. The answer to the calculus question is 0, which is evenly divisive by 20, giving the integer result 0, and is thus the zeroth multiple of 20.
d/dx of -4*sin(7x-pi/2) is 196 cos (7x)
Substitute for x=0 and you get 0
You can check by graphing and seeing that the tangent line is horizontal.
Admin
Admin
Admin
Admin
Oh, how much I like all those ATMs..
My "favorite" ATM is the one in our shopping mall... You select "200€" - and it will give you one 200€ note... Yeah...
Here in Germany many ATMs give you a fast cash option. But the values are always pre-defined by the bank. And the card is given back just before it gives you the money. Also you just have to enter the value, no cents.
When I was on vacation in India, I encountered many different types of ATMs. My favorite there was the one where I put in my card, then the screen changed to the company's logo with some indian letters on it. It looked like a loading screen to me. But someone pointed out to me, the machine wanted me to remove my card... It also featured a "do you want to make another transaction?" question at the end of the process. And the input of 20000.00 to get the right amount... What I found quite interesting is the amazing amount of questions one machine could ask before it gave me money. For withdrawal it had me go into the third submenu - and then some yes/no questions ("would you like to have a reciept?", ...)
I'm really happy about the simplicity of ATMs back here :-).
Admin
and then after that it says:
and then after that it goes back to the accounts menu.
This way is simple and fast, and doesn't have a error like the other one does, so therefore, this way is better way, at least in my opinion.
Admin
However, d/dx -4 sin (7x - pi/2) = -28 cos (7x - pi/2). Substituting x=0 here will get you -28 cos (-pi/2) which is indeed 0.
Admin
When will people in IT (nay, the world in general), learn that creating solutions for Stupid People breeds Stupid People. Keep it Simple, and people will find it usable. Many systems will have some quirks, of course, but they are still usable....
I hate (useless) questions especially when (as someone mentioned) there are several of them
"Would you like to make another transaction?" (I'm not capabale of reinserting my card? I got it right the first time, didn't I?) "Would you like a receipt?" (Why not always give a receipt - people should always keep receipts of any transaction they make anyway {Though I suspect the greenies are at fault on this one}) etc, etc....
It's almost as though people cater to the exception, not the rule.
From what most posters are saying, despite their (often petty) whinges, the ATM's they use work. They have seen odd behaviour, but haven't been fooled by quirks, or lost out because of unexpected behaviour.
Where's the Problem? The problem is people like a lot of these posters WORK (or at least are employed) in IT. They have wonderful ideas about making things foolproof. There is little need (I hate to say this but) the fool in the world is the exception not the rule. Treating the general population like fools wilkl only train them to become fools too.
</RANT>Oh, and get a life!!
Admin
I have seen many different types of ATMs, here in Australia.
So, there are many atm behaviours out there. Some are better than others.
The swipe a card style means you don't have to worry about the machine keeping your card, and the hassle for user and provider that entails - these are often used by third party atm providers, who set up atms in shops.
The ingest-regurgitate machines allow banks to capture stolen cards. Lately there are atms that regurgitate their card really slowly, which worries me that there is some John Connor style card reader just behind the slot.
The thing that bugs me at the moment is that eftpos swipes at supermarket checkouts have changed sides! It used to be that every swipe was stripe on the left, but now there are new consoles with stripe on the right.
As a courtesy to small retailers, I usually withdraw $60 (=3 x $20)when I want about $50 so that I don't hit them with $50 notes and take all their change, especially early in the morning. That means I always select "Other amount" which is why I see the different behaviours a lot.
Here's a wtf: the parallax error in lining up the screen display of options with the hardware buttons around the screen. The alignment seems to work if you are 4'6'' tall. If I stand normally, the buttons line up half way between the displayed tags, so I'm not sure what the buttons will do. I usually have to stoop a bit to line the buttons and tags up correctly.
I think the gui testing was done sitting down!
Admin
You epic-fail at math.
Sadly the value '0' is correct, although this is clearly no thanks to your ability at math.
Admin
Everyone is a UI designer. Including support staff. And me.
Admin
I suppose those keys could be reused for entering the PIN code too.
Admin
I always look inside the swipe thingy and find the read head and make the stripe on that side.